In Bryan's Words
The Dry Aged New York steak is probably the most popular of all the steaks and for understandable reasons. It delivers an extremely tender cut with very good flavor that can stand completely on its own with just salt and pepper. It delivers this with virtually no internal bits of fat (not to be confused with marbling, which it has in abundance). In fact, all the fat runs along one side and for those who wish to avoid it altogether have no difficulty whatsoever removing it.
The New York steak is cut from the largest section of the Dry Aged Shortloin, which for those of you crazy enough to try to ride one of these critters, is where you’d put the saddle. The New York comes in many different forms and names; when cut boneless, it’s called New York, New York Strip, Strip Sirloin, Striploin, and primarily in the New York City area the Shell Steak.
Its various manifestations include dry aged boneless new york, dry aged bone in new york strip (also called a Kansas City Strip),dry aged T-Bone, and as the predominant steak in the Porterhouse. In the porterhouse, it teams up with the Filet Mignon, while in the T-Bone it teams up with the bone (which is one reason I’m not a big fan of the T-Bone).
One end of the strip abuts the Prime Rib (where you’ll find the Ribeye steaks); literally the width of a knife separates the two cuts, and the other end will transition into the Top Sirloin or Chateaubriand. The end at the Chateaubriand is visually the less attractive of the two ends but is actually the more tender by nature; although we may be splitting hairs here, because the difference is indeed subtle when dry aged and would only be noticeable if the two cuts were tasted side by side.
For those of you who like to add a modern twist to classic cuts, a less common way to use the New York is to have it cut double thick (24oz), and then serve it in slices as you would a Chateaubriand.
These Dry Aged New York steaks start their life as part of a whole USDA Prime New York Shortloin, which we dry age in our carefully monitored aging coolers for 30-35 days. The dry aging process enhances the natural flavor of the beef and will give a more tender end result as well. While the New York Steak has the reputation of being king of cuts, our hand selected USDA Prime, Dry Aged Strips are simply the best dry aged steaks you can buy online.
Contrary to what you might have heard, the best way to determine the cooking time on a steak is by the thickness, rather than the weight.
On the Grill:
1” – 8 minutes total; 5 and 3
1¼“ – 9 minutes total; 7 and 3
1½“ – 14 to 15 minutes total; 10 and 4
2” – 15 to 18 minutes total; 11 and 5
2½“ – 20 minutes total; 12 and 8
3” – 25 minutes total; with such a thick cut you can really get creative here, and grill on all four sides. Turn the steak in a constant direction, and go 7 minutes on the first and second side, then drop to 5 minutes for the final two sides